**Content Notice: this sermon references sexual assault and the lawsuit against "the Cornell 7". Please take care of yourself, and skip reading or watching if hearing it discussed would be painful for you.**
Every time this story shows up in the lectionary, I cringe. This is a really hard passage both to read and to preach on, for what I think are fairly obvious reasons. But this time around, it feels a little bit harder than usual. This time, we’re reading it under the shadow of the allegations that have recently come out of Cornell - allegations made by a Jane Doe that are shocking, but sadly not all that surprising. As David demonstrates in today’s reading, those with any amount of privilege or power have always felt entitled to things that don’t belong to them - whether it’s another person’s property, their body, or their dignity. And as the Cornell case demonstrates, society is still disturbingly tolerant of this ongoing behavior.
In this case, there’s another aspect of the story that has captured the public’s attention. In addition to the allegations themselves, a text chain among members of the fraternity involved has sparked outrage of its own. In it, the seven men accused of assault crudely detail their actions and invite their fraternity brothers to join them. Only seven men actually participated in the alleged crime - but as many as 50 knew what was happening and did nothing. 50 men understood the situation yet chose to remain silent. How might things have turned out differently for Jane Doe, people are asking, if even one of these men had spoken up?
Although we don’t always realize it, “background characters” matter. Usually, when we encounter a story like this, we focus most of our attention on the perpetrators of the abuse. In the case of today’s scripture reading, this is obviously David. We debate what led him to sin so egregiously, how he might have justified his actions, and why he didn’t repent sooner. Occasionally, we might spare a thought for Bathsheba or Uriah, the victims of David’s terrible sin. But rarely, if ever, do we consider the role that the less visible characters play in the story: the messengers who David sent to abduct Bathsheba. Those who carried the news of Bathsheba’s pregnancy back to the king. Joab, the commander of Israel’s army. None of these figures received a text message describing David’s plans, but all of them knew exactly what was going on to one degree or another. And unsurprisingly, none of them - not a single one - said or did anything to stop it. How might things have turned out differently for Bathsheba, I wonder, if even one of these men had spoken up?
Bystanders have long been unwilling to stop harm being done right in front of them to others. We’ve all seen it - maybe we’ve even done it ourselves. There’s no shortage of excuses or justifications. “It was none of my business.” “I didn’t want to get in trouble.” “It wasn’t that big of a deal, really.” “Speaking up would have put a target on MY back.” “It wouldn’t have made a difference.” I could see any of the background characters in this passage defending themselves using any one of these excuses, and I can imagine the rest of us nodding along in sympathy. Of course you didn’t speak up! You can’t just confront the king! You don’t break the bro code! You don’t create trouble for yourself!
But while it appears that no one at Cornell was willing to stick their neck out for Jane Doe, someone WAS willing to speak up on Bathsheba’s behalf. Nathan was the court prophet - he was a trusted advisor and an insider to the royal household. He had as much to lose as anybody; possibly more. It certainly would have been in his personal best interest to keep quiet like everyone else. But he didn’t. He COULDN’T, because his prophetic role wouldn’t allow him to. Despite the enormous personal risk, Nathan stood up to David and preached God’s harsh judgement upon him.
Now, we have to be honest - Nathan’s intervention didn’t fix the situation. The harm had already been done: Bathsheba had already been violated and Uriah was already dead. David’s repentance, genuine as it was, could not make things right again. It’s also entirely possible that if someone in the Cornell text chain had objected to what was going on at the frat party, it wouldn’t have changed anything there either - and he likely would have wound up ostracized for his efforts. For all intents and purposes, both of these situations probably would have played out in exactly the same way as they did, whether anyone spoke up or not.
But that’s not the point. We can rarely undo bad things simply by speaking up. We can’t expect our voices alone to reverse the devastating power that sin, misogyny, selfishness, entitlement and so many other sins hold over humanity - especially not in a single statement. But when we take a stand against actions that are clearly, unequivocally wrong, we still accomplish *something.* When background characters like ourselves speak up, we’re refusing to let abuse be brushed off or swept under the rug. We’re refusing to make it easy to take advantage of others for personal benefit or pleasure. We’re refusing to let victims believe that they don’t matter. We’re refusing to let sin pass by unnamed and unchallenged. And that’s no small feat.
In a little over a week, the citizens of our nation will come together and vote to determine who will represent us for the next several years and what rules we want to live by as a community. Many of us have already cast our ballots, whether through absentee or early voting. It’s a right that most USAmericans cherish. But every election cycle, we also inevitably hear about those who choose not to exercise this right for one reason or another. Maybe it’s because they’re frustrated with the choices they feel they’ve been given. Maybe it’s because they don’t want to participate in a system that’s so profoundly flawed. Maybe it’s because they believe that their vote won’t make a difference, and that it’s not worth the effort and inevitable disappointment. Each one of these reasons is deeply relatable and, in my personal opinion, completely valid.
But your vote is more than just a mark on a paper or a tick in a ledger. It’s your voice. It’s your opportunity to reinforce the direction our society is headed in or - if you see harm being done - it’s your chance to speak out against it. You may feel like a background character in your own country, but your voice still matters. It’s your contribution to the group text. It’s your audience with King David. It’s your moment to take a stand.
We often call voting our patriotic duty or our civic responsibility, but it’s more than that. It’s also our moral obligation as Christians. Not as a way to mold the government into a Christian institution, but as a way to bear witness to the kindom of mercy and justice that God calls us to build, and to call out any and all who might be actively working against it. Your vote is a testimony to your understanding of the gospel. And while it’s always important to speak up in this way, Nathan reminds us that it’s especially so when you see systems of power hurting any of God’s beloved children.
We know that power, influence, and privilege can often lead people to do devastating harm to others. Not just harm against their bodies - although God knows there are plenty of ways to do that - but harm against their sense of self-worth, their autonomy, their identity, even their very existence. This is not a controversial take; it’s an observable fact that has been proven time and time again throughout human history, along every point of the power and political spectrums. And just as with those in David’s orbit and those in the Cornell text chain, we always have a chance to say something when we encounter it, to stand up against any wrongdoing that we see in those around us. It’s an opportunity that our faith obligates us to take, even if we don’t expect it to make a difference. Even if we think it will make us the target of ridicule or vengeance. Even if we’re the only one willing to do it.
So the question, I suppose, is not, “How are you voting?” or “Which politician do you support?” The question, for us, is “Who will I be? Will I be a cog in the machine like David’s messengers, doing exactly what I’m told? Will I be an agent of the establishment like Joab, protecting power for its own sake? Will I be like all of the silent bystanders throughout human history, passively watching things as they happen? Or will I be like Nathan, a voice determined to speak truth to power even when it feels risky or inconsequential? Will I be someone who spectates, or someone who speaks up?” This is the choice that we each have to make for ourselves. We have to decide if it’s worth it, to step out of the background and take a stand. It seems pretty clear what God thinks. But the choice is yours - who will you be? Amen.

No comments:
Post a Comment